David,
I m not saying it lightly: the end goal is censorship, no matter how nicely you try to put it.
The goal is to discourage people from posting. They call it peer pressure , which is nothing else but the politically correct equivalent expression for intimidation . The end result is censorship.
The idea of censoring the mailing lists has actually been mentioned very clearly in the recent discussions on -devel, and I never thought it would go past that, but it s actually happening. By the way, this could actually morph into a shitty karma system that wouldn t let you post past your monthly allowance and credit earned . How s that for you?
You refer to those +1/-1 mails; I find them silly, annoying, useless and a waste of bandwidth and CPU time. That used to be called a me too and generally despised and frowned upon.
If you actually want to score posts or posters, get a decent MUA and set up its scoring system the way you like. But keep that to yourself.
As
Aigars told, there are mail to web forum gateways (more like rendering engines for a mail archive, actually) that will present mails to a list in a crappy web forum of some sort that will come with all kind of crap like scoring, karma and whatever.
There s an essential difference between web forums and our mailing lists, though: forums of this kind use nicknames all over the place, our mailing lists use real names. There are privacy issues involved, and I m not giving up on that, either.
You want to stop flamewars? Stop replying, especially to tell how intolerable it is and other shit. Just let the damn thing die already. Funny how the well-meaning people are feeling harassed on the mailing lists when they, themselves, are harassing people they disagree with.
We don t all have the same views, culture etc. We re not all friends, and we probably never will be. Guess what? It s OK! Get over it and work with each other, because that is what we are here for. If you (general) can t get over it, I m afraid this Project is not the appropriate place for you.
Imposing a monoculture of politically correct crap is not an answer to the perceived problems .